You'd Never Guess New Jersey's Cheesiest Pizza Is Served At This Small-Town Spot

New Jersey's Cheesiest Pizza

Coniglio's Old Fashioned, a small-town pizzeria in Morristown, New Jersey, serves slices so cheesy you'll need two hands and plenty of napkins.

This no-frills pizzeria turns out pies that are big on flavor and heavy on the cheese, with each bite showing the care that goes into every bake.

Nino Coniglio spent years perfecting his craft in Brooklyn, where pizza standards are sky high and competition is fierce.

After building a solid reputation in the Big Apple, Nino decided to bring his talents to Morristown, showcasing his champion-level skills and dedication to quality ingredients.

Author's summary: Coniglio's Old Fashioned serves New Jersey's cheesiest pizza.

more

Ever After in the Woods Ever After in the Woods — 2025-10-15

More News