How did Jacob Elordi perform as The Creature? Fans of Guillermo del Toro were thrilled when the Oscar-winning director announced his own adaptation of Frankenstein, a project he had envisioned for nearly two decades. Known for his compassionate portrayal of monsters in films like Pan’s Labyrinth and The Shape of Water, del Toro's approach sparked great excitement.
However, one casting change dampened my initial enthusiasm. Just before production began in early 2024, Andrew Garfield left the project due to “scheduling conflicts,” and Jacob Elordi was announced as his replacement. This shift made me hesitant, despite Elordi's impressive work in Euphoria and Elvis.
After watching the film, which premiered on Netflix on November 7, I want to share my reflections on this decision.
Elordi brought a haunting intensity to the role, proving his talent in embodying complex characters. Yet, Andrew Garfield remains one of my all-time favorite actors, and initially, his departure felt like a loss for the project.
“Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein officially became part of upcoming horror movies when it was picked up by Netflix in 2023.”
While the initial news of the recasting was unsettling, experiencing Elordi’s performance within del Toro’s vision changed my perspective.
“Now that I’ve seen the movie – coming to those with a Netflix subscription on November 7, I need to talk about it.”
Author’s summary: The recasting of Frankenstein from Andrew Garfield to Jacob Elordi initially concerned me, but after watching the film, I appreciate Elordi’s performance within del Toro’s unique, compassionate monster story.