Josh Hutcherson's Controversial New HBO Show Sparks Fierce Critic & Audience Divide

Josh Hutcherson's New HBO Show Sparks Controversy

The HBO series I Love LA, which premiered on November 2, has created a strong divide between critics and viewers. The comedy, created by Rachel Sennott, follows a close group of friends reuniting after years apart, examining how their time away has affected them.

Critical Reception

Critics have praised I Love LA, giving it an 81% Certified Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 32 reviews. They describe it as an absurdist comedy that captures Gen Z humor and sensibilities well.

Sam Adams of Slate states the show's "writing gets sharper" as it progresses and appreciates its character development.
Chris Vognar from the Boston Globe highlights how the show turns its unlikable protagonists into sympathetic characters.

Audience Response

The audience reaction has been less favorable, with a 59% score from fewer than 50 ratings on Rotten Tomatoes. Some viewers enjoy the series' comedy and its appeal to young adults, while others criticize its stereotypical portrayal of Los Angeles and unsuccessful attempts at emotional depth.

Summary of Opinions

Overall, despite some critical acclaim, I Love LA remains divisive among viewers.

Author's summary: Josh Hutcherson’s HBO series divides opinion, praised for sharp writing and character depth by critics but criticized by audiences for clichés and emotional misfires.

more

Screen Rant Screen Rant — 2025-11-07