All’s Fair on Disney+ review: Kim Kardashian’s stilted new legal drama is a proper atrocity

All’s Fair on Disney+ Review

Ryan Murphy, known for his controversial style, has delivered one of the most disappointing shows on Disney+ with All’s Fair, starring Kim Kardashian.

Kim Kardashian’s Unconventional Path

Kim Kardashian, a pioneering influencer, has never followed the obvious path. In 2014, after marrying Kanye West at the Forte di Belvedere in Florence, they honeymooned not in a traditional luxury spot, but at lesser-known locations in Ireland, including Castlemartyr and a screening of X-Men: Days of Future Past in Portlaoise. This choice reflected her unique approach to life and fame.

The Show’s Reception and Cast

Now divorced from Kanye, Kardashian continues to defy expectations, showing little concern for critics as she stars in All’s Fair. Unfortunately, the show is widely regarded as a “proper atrocity” and one of the worst offerings on Disney+, rivaling even She-Hulk in quality.

Despite the criticism, Kardashian's star power has attracted a remarkable cast, including Naomi Watts and Glenn Close. However, Watts appears confused in her role, reminiscent of her awkward performance in Peter Jackson’s King Kong, and Close also seems visibly baffled.

Ryan Murphy, Hollywood’s laureate of bad taste, has produced one of the worst things Disney+ has ever foisted upon its subscribers.

Kim Kardashian continues to play by her own rules – and seems entirely indifferent as to how she will be judged.

All’s Fair is a proper atrocity exhibition and one of the worst things Disney+ has ever foisted upon its subscribers.

Author's summary: Kim Kardashian’s new legal drama All’s Fair is a chaotic misfire with confused performances, ranking among Disney+’s least successful series despite a star-studded cast.

more

The Irish Times The Irish Times — 2025-11-05